Sal's New York Pizza Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Sal's New York Pizza, where the heart of New York meets the Outer Banks! Located at 710 S Virginia Dare Trail, Kill Devil Hills, NC, Sal's offers a delightful array of authentic Italian dishes that are sure to satisfy any craving. Their New York-style pizza is a standout, featuring a perfectly thin and crispy crust topped with generous portions of fresh, quality ingredients.
- Starters include delicious Pizzacanes and flavorful Baked Meatballs, setting the stage for an unforgettable meal.
- For something unique, try their Specialty Topped Tots, which blend classic and innovative toppings.
- If you're in the mood for something hearty, the deluxe pizza is packed with savory selections that customers rave about.
The warm atmosphere, infused with the sounds of Frank Sinatra, makes dining at Sal's an experience you won't want to miss. The friendly staff and commitment to customer satisfaction solidify Sal's as a must-visit spot for pizza lovers in the OBX!
Starters
Bread Sticks
lightly topped w/ our garlic herb sauce & grated parmesan cheese
Wings
picante (hot), garlic herb (mild), carolina bbq, or vesuvius (extra hot)
Garlic Knots or Garlic Bread
w/ marinara sauce
Baked Meatballs
four housemade meatballs, baked w/ cheese & marinara sauce
Fried Shrimp
lightly coated in Italian seasoned bread crumbs, served w/ marinara
Spinach Artichoke Dip
topped w/ mozzarella, served bubbling hot w/ warm bread
Pizzacanes
spirals of pizza dough, filled with spicy pepperoni & cheese or mozzarella, pesto & peppers
Cold Antipasto
cured meats, cheese, olives, giardinara & pepperoncini, w/ focaccia
Caprese App
fresh mozzarella made in house, w/ tomatoes, peppers & pesto, drizzled w/ balsamic
Tater Tots
Try your tots topped! Order a basket & then choose your favorites from our pizza toppings menu. Melted cheese is $1 & topping prices are the same as the additions to the personal pizza
Classic
bacon & cheese w/ a side of ranch, add jalapeños
Supreme
all the supreme pizza toppings w/ a side of pizza sauce
Greek
feta, pepperoncini, olives, peppers, & spinach, w/ greek dressing
Carolina Style
pulled pork bbq, pickled red onions, & melted cheese
Specialty Topped Tots
New York Style Pizza
Plain Cheese
housemade lightly seasoned tomato sauce & fresh grated mozzarella cheese blend
Sauce Options
ricotta herb white, basil pesto, garlic herb, spicy tomato
Regular Toppings
mushrooms, onions, peppers, pepperoni, roast garlic, tomatoes, jalapeños, pineapple, extra cheese, spinach, olives, italian sausage, meatballs
Special Toppings #1
fresh mozzarella, chicken, ricotta, feta, pancetta, anchovies, broccoli, fried eggplant, soppresata, arugula salami, pork bbq or tater tots
Special Toppings #2
fried or garlic sautéed shrimp
Margherita
light tomato sauce, fresh basil, & housemade mozzarella
Bianca
roman style w/ garlic herb, parmesan, prosciutto & arugula
Four Cheese
white or red w/ mozzarella, ricotta, gorgonzola & provolone
Sal's New York White
ricotta & herb sauce w/ cheese, crispy pancetta, fresh broccoli & roast garlic
Shrimp & Pesto
garlic sautéed carolina shrimp (when available), basil pesto, & arugula
Spin-Art
spinach & artichoke sauce baked on our pizza, topped w/ light amount of mozzarella
Carolina BBQ
NC sauce, housemade pulled pork bbq, red onions, & mozzarella cheese
Specialty Pies
Pasta
Chicken Parmesan Pasta
herb breaded, baked w/ marinara & cheese, w/ gremolata linguini
Eggplant Parmesan Pasta
herb breaded, baked w/ marinara & cheese, w/ gremolata linguini
Shrimp Parmesan Pasta
herb breaded, baked w/ marinara & cheese, w/ gremolata linguini
Baked Spaghetti
marinara baked w/ mozzarella cheese & finished w/ gremolata
Baked Tortellini Marinara
cheese tortellini in our marinara sauce baked w/ mozzarella cheese
Baked Tortellini ala Pesto
cheese tortellini in pesto cream, baked w/ mozzarella & our herbed bread crumbs
Penne Parmesan
penne baked in a parmesan cream sauce topped w/ mozzarella & herbed bread crumbs
Penne a la Vodka
penne in the classic sauce w/ sweet onions, vodka, cream, tomato & parmesan
Pastas
linguini, tortellini, spaghetti or penne
Sauce
marinara, parmesan cream, spicy tomato, garlic butter, or pesto
Make it "Baked"
add oven melted mozzarella $2
M.Y.O. Pasta
Classic Pies
Extra Meaty
All Veggie
Deluxe
Takes an extra 10 minutes
Prosciutto & Mozzarella
thinly sliced prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, & arugula on focaccia
Chicken Pesto
seared chicken, pesto, roasted red peppers & provolone w/ arugula on focaccia
Turkey & Bacon
thinly sliced turkey, crispy bacon & swiss cheese, w/ dijon on sub roll
Spicy Italian
salami, pepperoni, soppresata, provolone & red peppers, w/ spicy pepper spread
Paninis
Hot & Cold Subs
Eggplant Parmesan
herb breaded, baked w/ marinara & cheese, finished w/ gremolata
Chicken Parmesan
herb breaded, baked w/ marinara & cheese, finished w/ gremolata
Shrimp Parmesan
herb breaded, baked w/ marinara & cheese, finished w/ gremolata
Sausage & Peppers
italian sausage, onions & green peppers, w/ melted provolone cheese & gremolata
Baked Meatball Marinara
four house made meatballs, baked w/ marinara & cheese, w/ gremolata
Caprese Sub
fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, pesto, roasted red peppers & arugula, w/ balsamic
Italian Sub (Hot Or Cold)
soppresata, salami, pepperoni, provolone w/ lettuce, tomato, & onion
Turkey & Swiss (Hot Or Cold)
roasted, sliced turkey, swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion & mayo
Lentil Soup
made in-house, w/ fresh vegetables & herbs
Tomato Basil
tomato & cream soup finished w/ a touch of pesto
Soups
Salads
Classic Caesar
house made garlic croutons, romaine, & parmesan, casear dressing, anchovies on request
Caprese Salad
housemade fresh mozzarella, peppers, fresh tomatoes, basil, over mixed greens
House Salad
mixed greens, red onion, tomato, carrot & cucumber slices
Antipasto Salad
pepperoni, soppresata, salami, olives, pepperoncini, provolone, over our house salad
Greek Salad
feta, olives, pepperoncini, roasted red peppers & roasted garlic, served over our house salad
Chef Salad
sliced turkey, crumbled bacon, provolone & swiss, hard boiled egg over our house salad
Cheesecake
w/ cherry or strawberry sauce
Cannoli
w/ chocolate chips
Cookie or Brownie Slice
Desserts
Gremolata
Gremolata
gre.mo.la.ta /,grema'lada. we put it on everything! A blend of lemon zest, garlic, parsley & oil