Welcome to Sal's New York Pizza
At Sal's New York Pizza, we celebrate authentic Italian flavors with a true New York vibe. Located in Kill Devil Hills, NC, our relaxed atmosphere sets the stage for delicious meals that feel like a slice of the Big Apple. Our signature New York-style pizza boasts a perfectly crisp crust and generous toppings, a crowd favorite among locals and tourists alike. Beyond pizza, our menu features delightful starters like house-made mozzarella and baked meatballs. With friendly service and classic tunes, dining at Sal's is an unforgettable experience that leaves you craving more. Join us for a taste of NYC tradition!
-
710 S Virginia Dare Trail, Kill Devil Hills, NC 27948 Hotline: (252) 715-3145
Welcome to Sal's New York Pizza, an iconic Italian pizzeria located at 710 S Virginia Dare Trail in lovely Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina. Renowned for its authentic New York-style pizza, Sal's has quickly become a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike. With a phone number for convenience at (252) 715-3145, it's never been easier to enjoy a slice of New York right here on the Outer Banks.
What sets Sal's apart? The answer lies in their commitment to quality and tradition. Step inside this classic joint, and you’ll be greeted by a warm atmosphere reminiscent of bustling NYC pizzerias. The moment you take your first bite, you're met with a perfectly chewy yet crispy crust, generous toppings, and a symphony of flavors that dance on your palate. As customer Mark G. put it, “This is a classic joint, which is exactly what you’d find in NY—and this is a good thing.”
Aside from the star attraction—pizza—Sal's offers a robust menu filled with mouthwatering starters. Indulge in crispy tater tots topped with your favorite pizza toppings, savory garlic knots, or the delightful Pizzacanes, spirals of pizza dough filled with spicy pepperoni and cheese. Wings, cooked to perfection, come in flavors ranging from garlic herb to Carolina BBQ, making them an excellent pairing with any pizza order.
But let’s not forget the star of the show: the specialty New York Style Pizza. Choose from a range of sauce options, including ricotta herb white and spicy tomato, and pile on your favorite toppings. Recommendations from satisfied patrons include the deluxe pizza, loaded with flavors that’ll leave your taste buds tingling and your hunger sated. Ken D. raves, “I have found the BEST PIZZA in the OBX!”
- Specialty Topped Tots: Experience a twist on traditional toppings with options like Greek-inspired feta and Carolina pulled pork BBQ.
- Garlic Butter Knots: Soft, buttery, and served with marinara, perfect for sharing—or not!
- Seasoned Fried Shrimp: Lightly coated and paired with marinara, giving a coastal flair to your meal.
Sal's New York Pizza doesn’t just serve delicious food; their staff consistently goes above and beyond, ensuring that each guest has an enjoyable experience. Ellen S. noted their accommodating nature, especially during busy times, and the delightful ambiance filled with Frank Sinatra tunes—creating the perfect backdrop for family gatherings or a casual night out.
In conclusion, whether you’re a local or a tourist, Sal’s New York Pizza is a must-visit eatery in the Outer Banks. With its scrumptious menu, friendly service, and authentic atmosphere, they’ve crafted a dining experience that will have you adding them to your list of favorites. So next time cravings strike, consider Sal's—where every bite takes you back to the heart of New York City.
Recently wanted to get pizza, but our "regular" places were closed so thought we'd give Sal's a try. What a find! This is a classic joint, which is exactly what you'd find in NY - and this is a good thing. The pizza did not disappoint. The crust had a great chew to it, thin and crispy, and generous toppings. We saw others there that got the lasagna or baked spaghetti and based on their reactions it was as good as it looked. The only disappointment is that we didn't try Sal's before now. It is now part of our "regular" places.
Without a doubt it's the best pizza on the OBX. The staff is great and the food was ready on time. While it's not the fanciest place it's a great local restaurant.
We ate at Sal's tonight. They do not have a lot of seating space but accommodated our group for our son's 16th birthday with no hesitation. I was so impressed with their professionalism as they answered phone orders and walk ins with estimated wait times. It is a Sunday and a huge cottage turnover day - pizza and subs are no brainers for tourists and they non-apologetically gave honest answers. I loved this! The atmosphere made me so happy with tons of Frank Sinatra music. We ordered wings, garlic knots, a 18 inch pepperoni pizza and a deluxe. Everyone was pleased with the tastes. The wait staff was kind and attentive. I highly recommend this establishment.
Absolutely outstanding pizza. We got the several large pizzas and they were very good. I highly recommend the deluxe pizza, it is absolutely loaded (everything except fish and fruit).
Fantastic service, delicious pizzas... absolutely worth visiting when in OBX... we also did a take out order!
So tonight we tried Sals pizza for the first time we have dined here before and love this place. I am incredibly happy tosay I have found the BEST PIZZA in the OBX! PERFECT CRUST , by the far the best pizza I have since we moved here! It's a must stop for any of their meals. I am now a total fan of this place.